1 Timothy 6:16 – ‘God alone possesses immortality’
1 Timothy 6:16 — ‘[God] alone possesses immortality and lives in unapproachable light, whom no human has ever seen or is able to see. To him be honor and eternal power! Amen.’
The fundamental meaning of this text is not really in dispute. Every theist – certainly every Christian theist – will affirm that God is not subject to death or decay.
Debate arises, however, when we consider whether the immortal God communicates immortality to all or some members of the human race.
There are two possible answers:
(a) God communicates immortality to every human creature. Immortality is a part of God’s image in humankind.
(b) Humankind forfeited immortality as a consequence of the Fall. Immortality is a gift conferred on the regenerate, and on them only.
If the first is true, then, every person is indestructable, and is destined either to enjoy everlasting bliss or to suffer everlasting punishment.
If the second is true the righteous will enjoy everlasting bliss, but the unrighteous will eventually pass out of existence.
It is not surprising, then, that proponents of conditional immortality appeal to this text, arguing that since God alone has immortality in and of himself, the immortality of human creatures need not (and indeed does not) extend to all, but only to those who receive the gift of ‘eternal life’. Others, it is asserted, suffer eternal death (i.e. annihilation).
Those who teach the immortality of the human soul might argue:-
(a) that although God alone is immortal in himself, he communicates immortality to others. This was the view of Calvin. Matthew Henry comments:
‘He only has immortality; he only is immortal in himself, and has immortality as he is the Fountain of it, for the immortality of angels and spirits is derived from him’.
For some, the immortality of the human soul derives from our being made in God’s image: according to the Westminster Confession: ‘‘After God had made all other creatures, he created man, male and female, with reasonable and immortal souls’.
Calvin, as noted above, taught that, although God alone is immortal, he confers immortality on human beings. Philip Hughes summarises and critiques Calvin’s position:-
‘In his comments on 1 Tim 6: 16 Calvin made it plain that he did not regard immortality as inseparable from human nature or from the essence of the soul. “I reply, when it is said, that God alone possesses immortality,” he wrote, “it is not here denied that he bestows it, as he pleases, on any of his creatures.” To say God alone is immortal is to imply that he “has immortality in his power; so that it does not belong to creatures, except so far as he imparts to them power and vigour.” This means, further, that “if you take away the power of God which is communicated to the soul of man, it will instantly fade away.” Thus Calvin concluded that “Strictly speaking, therefore, immortality does not subsist in the nature of souls . . . but comes from another source, namely, the secret inspiration of God.”
‘The question that remains unanswered in the position represented by Calvin is this: if it is granted that immortality is a gift imparted by God and, further, that the being to whom it is imparted would “instantly fade away” were God’s power to be removed, what grounds are there for concluding that immortality is a permanent gift that will not under any circumstances be removed, and accordingly that no rational being will ever relapse into nonexistence, or, in other words, suffer destruction? It is a conclusion that…seems to rest largely on the supposition that the endless bliss of the redeemed requires to be balanced by the endless punishment of the damned.’
in Christopher M. Date, Gregory G. Stump, Joshua W. Anderson. Rethinking Hell: Readings in Evangelical Conditionalism.
(b) that although the human body is mortal, the soul is immortal. Swete (The Life of the World to Come) comments:
‘God is immortal in the sense that he cannot die . . . God “only hath immortality” such as this. Man is immortal in the sense that there is in him that which does not die. His body dies, but his soul survives. It lives on after it has left the body. His identity is not lost when he dies; his true self, the ultimate being and personality of the man, remains as it was before death . . . Not all of him dies; there is a part of him, and by far the more essential [which cannot die].’ (Cited by Fudge, The Fire That Consumes, 3rd ed.)
Hughes argues:
‘Man’s formation in the image of God does indeed imply his possession of life in a manner that transcends that of other animate creatures; but it cannot mean the possession of life in the same sense as that in which God possesses it, if only because God possesses life absolutely, from eternity to eternity, whereas man possesses it derivatively and subject to the good pleasure of his Creator. The immortality of man or of the human soul is not then a necessary conclusion from this premise.’ (Christopher M. Date, Gregory G. Stump, Joshua W. Anderson. Rethinking Hell: Readings in Evangelical Conditionalism.)
Conclusion
It seems to me that this verse is not decisive in the debate as to whether all, or only some, human beings are immortal (in this derived sense); the argument that, since only God is immortal, none of his creatures can be, ignores the very real possibility of conferred immortality. Hence:
‘if it proves anything, proves too much. In fact, God who alone has immortality in himself may and does communicate it to some of his creatures.’ (Nicole, EDT, 2nd ed., art. ‘Annihilationism’)
The question would then be: does God confer immortality on all members of the human race, or only on some (the regenerate)?
The picture needs to be filled out – insofar as it can be filled out – by reference to a wider range of biblical material. This should include (a) whether Scripture teaches some form of mind/body dualism (such that the soul is capable of surviving the death of the body); (b) a consideration of the biblical emphasis on resurrection (rather than immortality) as the focus of the life to come (cf. 1 Cor 15:53f, which implies that everlasting life is something that is conferred at the end of the age, rather than a pre-existent state.)