Body and/or soul? – The nature of the human person
Bruce Milne (Know the Truth, 3rd ed.,) discusses whether a human being has distinct “parts” or is a single unity. He sets out three views.
1. Dichotomy vs. trichotomy (body and soul, or body, soul and spirit)
- Dichotomists argue that Scripture uses “soul” and “spirit” interchangeably. Examples are death as giving up the soul or the spirit, and the dead being called both “souls” and “spirits”.
- Trichotomists rely mainly on Hebrews 4:12 and 1 Thessalonians 5:23. The passage says neither verse is conclusive. Hebrews 4:12 describes God’s Word exposing the whole person, and 1 Thessalonians 5:23 describes God sanctifying the whole person.
- Some, including Wesley and Watchman Nee, hold that a person is a dichotomy before regeneration and a trichotomy afterwards. The passage doubts this. It warns that it can lead to the claim that the Holy Spirit is the believer’s “third element”. It calls this theologically precarious and pastorally hazardous, because people may treat their own impulses as God’s voice.
2. Unity of the person (dual-aspect monism)
- Today the debate has largely moved to dualism versus a Christian monism. Monism rejects physicalism, the view that humans are only matter.
- Monists argue that:
- “Soul” and “spirit” overlap in meaning and have a wide range of uses, including for animals and for the whole person.
- The body–soul split came from Greek philosophy, especially Plato.
- The relationship between body and soul is hard to define.
- Neuroscience shows how closely brain and consciousness are linked.
- The resurrection of the body points to the person’s unity.
3. The dualist response (holistic dualism)
- God is non-bodily spirit, and angels may also be disembodied. So being a person does not require a body.
- Dualists cite Genesis 2:7, Ecclesiastes 12:7 and Ezekiel 37. They also cite OT and NT texts about life after death, including Luke 20:38, Luke 23:43, Philippians 1:23 and Matthew 10:28.
- Greek influence is admitted, but John W. Cooper shows that intertestamental Judaism already described disembodied persons. Dualists therefore see the idea as developing from OT teaching.
- Mystery about how the parts relate is expected. It is comparable to the Trinity, the two natures of Christ and divine sovereignty with human responsibility. Some philosophers also argue for the irreducibility of the person.
- Dualists must avoid devaluing the material side of life. That means not ranking “spiritual” vocations above ordinary work, not taking a negative view of sexuality, and not neglecting care for the earth and its creatures.
(Summarised using Microsoft Copilot, and checked for accuracy)
Clear and helpful as this account is, various questions remain unanswered (possibly unanswerable). For example: monists must presumably deny the existence of any intermediate state, but this would seem to many to contradict many relevant scriptural texts.