The notions of ‘satisfaction’ and ‘substitution’ in relation to atonement are often seen as crude and primitive. Indeed, the idea that God would need to be appeased by the cruel sacrifice of his Son is frequently thought to be inconsistent with the character and teaching of Jesus himself.
But, in fact, such ideas, carefully stated, lie at the heart of the church’s worship and witness. Cranmer, for example, at the beginning of his Prayer of Consecration in 1549 described Jesus as having made on the cross, by his ‘one oblation of himself once offered’, ‘a full, perfect, and sufficient sacrifice, oblation, and satisfaction for the sins of the whole world’.…