Is Genesis 1 non-binary?
Genesis 1:27 — ‘God created humankind in his own image, in the image of God he created them, male and female he created them.’
It has become fashionable to read this text as teaching, or at least implying, a non-binary view of male and female.
Christina Beardsley writes:
‘Genesis 1:27 ‘male and female He created them’ is often quoted to support the view that the Creator, or nature, offer human beings only two options, man or woman, and that one’s birth sex is a ‘given’ that one should not seek to alter. What this verse actually says – ‘God created man in his own image; in the image of God he created him; male and female He created them’ – broadens its meaning considerably, placing the emphasis, not so much on the policing of gender boundaries, but on the dignity of human beings, men and women, made in the image of God.’
Sharon Ferguson writes:
‘If you start with Genesis, it says in the Hebrew that God created both male and female – making it clear that every human is male and female. It’s just a societal construct that we are either/or.’
This is plainly absurd. When a cook says, ‘I made chocolate buns and plain buns’, does he means that every bun is a mixture of chocolate and plain? I don’t think so.
More plausibly, Steve Chalke argues:
‘Although Genesis 1 speaks of the stark contrasts of the binary nature of God’s creation: ‘man and woman’, ‘earth and sea’, ‘day and night’ or ‘plants and animals’, he (or to be more faithful to the biblical texts he/she) also creates the beautiful ‘half-ways’ of lakes and rivers, and dawns and dusks.’ (The Gender Agenda)
This thought is possibly an echo (conscious or unconscious). As Martin Davie notes:
‘In his book Trans-Gendered (Cleveland: The Pilgrim Press 2003) the American writer Justin Tanis argues that the Genesis account ‘even while differentiating between elements of creation, still leaves space for ‘in between’ things: dusk, dawn, intersexed persons. God blesses all these parts of creation calling them good’ (p.59).’
However [comments Davie],
‘the examples he gives of in-between things, such as dawn, dusk or the sea shore, are actually examples of names for times or places at the edge of things (dawn or dusk at the beginning or end of the day, and the sea shore at the end of the land) they do not describe mixed things.’ (Glorify God in Your Body)